Trololol: To Carthage Then I Came
In July 2014, Irish artist D. Joyce-Ahearne’s work was exhibited at the Museum of Modern Art in New York. The exhibit, entitled Trololol: To Carthage Then I Came, was as controversial as it was short-lived. Following widespread outrage at the work on display, MoMA pulled the exhibit after only two days and shut the Des Connery Gallery in which it had been displayed, indefinitely. The space is to be reopened in spring 2015 under a new name, the museum having decided to shed the moniker of the notorious art critic.
The debacle was underplayed by the art world, with few outlets willing to discuss Joyce-Ahearne’s work. All references to the exhibit were removed from MoMA’s website and social media. The artist quickly distanced himself from the exhibit and in a statement released shortly afterwards, Joyce-Ahearne said that he had destroyed all traces of the work: “All models, rough sketches, casts, anything that went into Trololol is gone. There’s nothing left of it.”
Very few photographs taken by the public have surfaced. Last month however, a series of photographs taken at the exhibit appeared online. The photos, which appear to have been rushed and are in places blurry, are the only known record of the exhibit. They have seen little airing in the media, with few willing to comment on a topic which many happily believed to be buried.
The exhibition information as it appeared in the gallery, reproduced below (end of text missing)
“It was with the work of D. Joyce-Ahearne (Irish, born 1993) in mind that the Museum of Modern Art commissioned the Des Connery Gallery, named after the infamous and late French-Irish critic. The gallery, the museum’s smallest to date, is curated by the artist and designed to highlight his work in a way that frames it in a setting comfortable to the viewer.
Joyce-Ahearne’s concerns, since his first exhibit, have been the nature of art, theory, people and museums, rather than these things themselves. His project is finding art in museums, theory in art, museums in art, art in theory, theory in people, people in art and museums in museums.
Des Connery, with his irreverent and unique turn of phrase, described Joyce-Ahearne’s early work as ‘what will be described as his early work’, glowing praise from so discerning a critic, as it presumes that someone in the future will still be discussing Joyce-Ahearne’s work at all. However no one could have predicted that people would be talking about it so soon or that Connery would not be around to critique it, having taken his own life as part of his last exhibit.
When MoMA approached Joyce-Ahearne with the possibility of an…”
The Des Connery Gallery, showing the work Self-Portrait?
Portrait of Two Women (information reproduced below)
“Though it is unknown who the models are that sat for the portrait, they are believed to be twins. The original and its many copies adorn a Park Avenue apartment that Joyce-Ahearne was commissioned to decorate several years ago while working in the city.
The vague expression on the women’s faces, which are almost identical, have drawn obvious comparisons to Leonardo da Vinci’s Mona Lisa, though many see Joyce-Ahearne’s Portrait of Two Women more favourably, as he evokes much the same sense of mystery with more subtlety.
The dreamy expressions recorded in the portrait have meant that innumerable interpretations have been aired, from incest to ennui. Asked for this exhibit, the artist described the deliberate vagueness of the faces as offering ‘an outlet for whatever people wish to project onto the piece and thereby possibly learn more about themselves.’”
I.C.B.U.T. A work attributed to an unknown Conor Marron
I.C.B.U.T, a work displaying a crudely bearded Rrose Sélavy (a pseudonym for the French artist Marcel Duchamp), though part of Joyce-Ahearne’s exhibition, was attributed to an unknown artist named Conor Marron. Marron, in turn, is now considered to be a pseudonym for Joyce-Ahearne himself, the name believed to be a pun on the French connard marrant.
Leveller (information reproduced below, text missing)
“Leveller was deliberately chosen as the…
gallery’s namesake who famously axiomed: “A…
work was actually one of the last pieces on dis…
conceived during a particularly crippling period…
‘The idea for Leveller came to me as I wa…
Space and Language to Bright Colours. I was str…
concept and decided to sleep on it. When I turn…
struggle with the piece. It was then that the nam…
the same time I conceived Leveller.’
The interactive Leveller means the observ…
work, while partaking in the art itself. The obvio…
‘The Starry Night’ have been drawn, some claim…
between “inspiration” and “plagiarism”, an accus…”
Self-Portrait? (information reproduced below)
“Jaded by the constant scenes of people taking pictures of themselves in front of works of art with their backs to them, Joyce-Ahearne devised an interactive installation that would allow people to ‘create something new, rather than literally stand in the way of art.’
With the frequency of people coming to the museum just to record the fact that they had seen pieces (or could have seen them had they turned around), the artist decided to attack this mass indifference to art by taking it to its logical conclusion, that is, by encouraging people to just photograph themselves in front of the art, rather than appreciate it.
By harnessing something unquestionably negative and redirecting it towards creating something new, the photographs taken in front of Self-Portrait? are unique and full of an artistic vibrancy that inverts the sadness of people taking photos of themselves in front of famous paintings.
Photographs taken in front of Self-Portrait? cannot be curated with ‘Look at what I saw’ but rather ‘Look at what I am’ or ‘Look at what I made.’
Whether the inclusion of the hashtag is art, a cynical piece of self-promotion or an artistic pastiche of cynical self-promotion is left open to the public to discuss on Instagram and Twitter.”
Since the photographs have emerged, Joyce-Ahearne has denied that it is him in the above photo, despite a definite resemblance to the man pictured. Conspiracy theories have abounded since the leak, with some suggesting that the man is Des Connery and that the critic, in fact, faked his own death.
Other theories include that Joyce-Ahearne is an alter ego of Connery or that Joyce-Ahearne is perhaps the alter ego of Connor Marron (rather than the other way around). Some conspiracies go as high up as suggesting that MoMA themselves orchestrated the entire debacle and that Des Connery himself never existed but is rather an eighty year old experiment in conceptual art.
A blurred photo of The Curationist Myth, Joyce-Ahearne’s most controversial work (gallery information reproduced below)
“Perhaps the most shocking piece of Joyce-Ahearne’s work so far, The Curationist Myth has been decried by many as being a step too far. Turned down by countless galleries as being ‘pure insanity’, MoMA accepted the piece as part of Trololol: To Carthage Then I Came, recognising it as, if not the crowning piece of the exhibit, then at the very least the cornerstone on which the entire concept of play between art, ideas, people and museums rests.
The dichotomy of eternal serenity and crushing despair that the piece radiates comes from the realisation that it goes on forever. Its undertones of anguish and awareness of the abyss is softened by its very nature: it is curated. It is what it is.”
The Curationist Myth was the exhibit’s most controversial piece and widely accepted as the reason the exhibition was shut down. The piece consists of an information sign which gives the title of the piece and the materials of which it is composed, which simply reads “This”. The work is then curated by a copy of the same sign.
The Curationist Myth, which calls the very idea of a museum into question, resulted in hundreds of visitors demanding their money back from MoMA, having been convinced by the work that museums were an absurd idea.
D. Joyce-Ahearne is a third year English and French student and the current Deputy-Editor of Trinity News. He has had poetry published in both Irish and English, both in Ireland and abroad. His short fiction has appeared in The Bohemyth, The Incubator and berfrois. Last year, he wrote and directed his first play. https://twitter.com/D_JoyceAhearne